KV TechLegal
Back to insights

IT Act and intermediary compliance

India blocked 129 websites on court orders that never existed

Written by Hirendhar Lakshmanan, Partner. 2026-11-18. 6 min read.

Reuters reported on November 11 2026 that the Department of Telecommunications had told internet providers to block 129 betting websites on two High Court orders sent in by email, and that neither court has any record of them.

The first order arrived on a Sunday night

The first order reached DoT at 8:59 pm on Sunday, July 19, by email from "Aryan Chaudhary", who described himself as an advocate-on-record. It carried the Rajasthan High Court's name and seal, cited the IT Act's power to block content in the interest of national security, and asked for action within 24 hours.

On July 21 DoT told internet providers to block 34 betting websites "as specified in the court order as per the enclosed list". When Reuters later wrote to the sender's address, the email bounced as "Recipient not found".

The second took eleven days and an action taken report

The second order, dated August 14, carried the name of Justice Garima Prashad of the Allahabad High Court and the title Sahil Singh v. The Director General (DIT Cyber Law), MeitY & Ors., Writ-A No. 30480 of 2026. Someone calling himself advocate Kartikey Pandey emailed it to officials on August 22.

DoT's published correspondence, as Reuters reported it, shows several exchanges among officials after that, in which they asked for an "action taken report". On September 2 an official told internet providers to "take immediate necessary action in respect of blocking access" to 95 betting websites. DoT uses the same words in its letters on genuine court orders, including one of October 15 2026 in a Delhi High Court piracy case.

The QR code led to a page with only a case number

The Allahabad order carried the court's logo, a blue seal with the national emblem and a QR code, and Reuters found that the code led to a random page showing a single line, the case number.

Genuine orders look much the same. The Delhi High Court orders that DoT forwards to internet providers carry a QR code and a line saying their authenticity "can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code". Scanning the code helps only if someone checks that it opens the court's own website and shows the same order.

Neither court has any record of the orders

The Rajasthan High Court's registrar told Reuters the order bearing its name "appears to be fraudulent" and did not exist on the court's server. In Allahabad, the judge's office confirmed that "no such order has been passed by Her Ladyship", and the High Court filed a police complaint on November 6 after Reuters raised questions. Uttar Pradesh police are investigating unknown persons for forgery and cheating, and Reuters reported no arrests.

Reuters could not find out who made the orders or why, or whether AI was used. The documents did not need it, since a seal, an invented case number, a judge's name and a QR code that led nowhere got them through.

DoT has lifted the Allahabad blocks

On November 13 DoT told every internet provider to unblock the 95 Allahabad sites "with immediate effect", in a letter that gives no reason and whose date line still reads "#ApprovedDate#". A second letter the same day lifted a block on 16 sites that DoT had ordered on August 14 in a Manipur district court case, State of Manipur v. GoDaddy LLC & Ors., again without a reason.

No published letter covers the 34 Rajasthan sites. When we checked DoT's July to September list on November 17, it had no entry for July 21, and the September 2 entry had no file attached.

Press reports indicate that the Prime Minister's Office summoned Telecom Secretary Amit Agrawal on November 14, and that the ministry has opened an internal investigation while police seek its records.

X received forged police notices in the same weeks

On November 6 X told the Delhi High Court that police orders asking it to block the accounts of the Internet Freedom Foundation and SFLC.in were fake. According to Reuters, they had been submitted through X's online reporting form in the name of a senior Delhi police officer, accused the two groups of defaming the RSS, and invoked rules requiring platforms to act within three hours.

X forwarded them to the groups before establishing they were fake, and its lawyer later told the court that "somebody impersonating Delhi police" had sent them.

The rules set a three-hour deadline and no way to check

Under rule 3(1)(d) of the IT Rules, a platform gets "actual knowledge" of unlawful content in only two ways: an order of a court of competent jurisdiction, or a reasoned written intimation from an officer authorised by order in writing, of at least Joint Secretary rank or, for the police, Deputy Inspector General. Since February 20 2026 it must remove the content within three hours.

Court-ordered blocks reach internet providers through DoT, which forwards the order with a list of sites, sometimes one received from the plaintiff's counsel. Nothing in either route tells the recipient how to confirm that the order, or the officer, is real, and the two forgeries copied exactly those two forms.

How to check an order within three hours

An internet provider, registrar, platform or company holding data can run these checks before acting.

  1. (i) Look up the case number on the issuing court's own website and compare the order there with the copy you received.
  2. (ii) Open the QR code and confirm that it leads to the court's own domain.
  3. (iii) Check the sender against the Supreme Court's published list of advocates-on-record or the state Bar Council roll, and reply through an address you found yourself.
  4. (iv) For a government intimation, ask for the officer's written authorisation and check the rank against rule 3(1)(d).
  5. (v) Keep a record of each check and of what you relied on.

If the blocked site is yours

DoT's blocking letters go to internet providers, MeitY and the plaintiff's counsel, and the owner of the blocked site is not on the list, so the first sign of a block may be customers who cannot reach the site.

DoT publishes the letters on its website, grouped by quarter under "Blocking Notifications/instructions to Internet Service Licensees under court orders", and a business can search those lists for its own domains. If one appears, the issuing court's own record shows whether the order is real, and the remedy lies with that court, or in a writ petition if no such order exists.

Brands that send their own orders to DoT, registrars or platforms may now face more questions, and can answer them quickly by sending a certified copy or a court-portal link from an address the recipient can verify.

Data fiduciaries face the same risk with data requests

From May 13 2027, section 36 of the DPDP Act lets the Central Government call for information from a Data Fiduciary, and rule 23 of the DPDP Rules says it does so through the authorised person named in the Seventh Schedule. Section 17(1)(c) exempts processing for preventing, detecting, investigating or prosecuting offences, but it expressly keeps section 8(5), the duty to take reasonable security safeguards against a personal data breach.

Those requests have the capability to be forged as a court order. Personal data handed to an impostor fits the definition of a personal data breach in section 2(u), which brings in intimation to the Board and each affected Data Principal under section 8(6), and a failure of safeguards under section 8(5) carries a penalty of up to 250 crore rupees.

This is our reading of the Act. No court or Board has yet applied it to a forged request.

What DoT could change

DoT could close much of the gap itself by taking court orders through an authenticated channel instead of email, checking each one against the court's own records before blocking, telling the site owner, and giving reasons when it lifts a block.

Sources

  1. Reuters, "India ordered website takedowns on fake court orders, Reuters finds; police launch probe", November 11 2026.
  2. Reuters, "X says police order demanding removal of Indian free-speech groups' accounts was fake", November 6 2026.
  3. Reuters, "Modi's office summons telecom secretary over use of fake court orders, officials say", November 14 2026.
  4. Department of Telecommunications, unblocking instructions in Writ-A No. 30480 of 2026 (Allahabad) and Misc. Criminal Application No. 18 of 2026 (Churachandpur, Manipur), November 13 2026.
  5. Department of Telecommunications, instructions in CS(COMM) 1361 of 2025 (Delhi High Court), October 15 2026.
  6. Department of Telecommunications, "Blocking Notifications/instructions to Internet Service Licensees under court orders", July to September and October to December 2026 lists, viewed November 17 2026.
  7. Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021, rule 3(1)(d), as amended by G.S.R. 775(E), October 22 2025, and G.S.R. 120(E), February 10 2026.
  8. Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, sections 2(u), 8(5), 8(6), 17(1)(c), 36 and the Schedule; Digital Personal Data Protection Rules, 2025, rule 23 and Seventh Schedule; G.S.R. 843(E) and G.S.R. 846(E), November 13 2025.

Topics

This note is a general account of the law at the date shown. It is not legal advice.

Related notes