KV TechLegal
Back to insights

Data protection and privacy

Is your neighbour's camera a Data Fiduciary?

Written by KV TechLegal. 2026-11-13. 9 min read.

On 26 October 2026, the Allahabad High Court held that no private CCTV camera may be positioned to interfere with a neighbour's privacy. We read the order against the DPDP Act's exclusion for personal or domestic processing, which takes effect on 13 May 2027.

A four-paragraph order

Yogendra Maurya complained that his neighbour's camera exposed the entry to and exit from his house and interfered with the privacy of anyone visiting or leaving it. A Division Bench of Justices Ajit Kumar and Garima Prashad held:

[N]o private CCTV camera can be installed and positioned in such a manner as to interfere with the privacy of a neighbour.

The Bench directed the petitioner to apply to the District Magistrate, who must decide within a month. The order cites no statute or precedent, and it does not say what power the District Magistrate is to exercise or what test applies.

What the courts have done so far

Indian courts have handled neighbour cameras mostly by asking whether the camera looks into someone else's home.

CaseWhat the court did
Sumehar Chand Narwal v. State of H.P. (Himachal Pradesh HC, 2024)Quashed a stalking charge because there was no proof the camera was directed towards the complainant's house
Sivasankaran v. State of Kerala (Kerala HC, 2025)Refused to order three neighbours, one of them an 80-year-old woman, to remove their cameras, holding that removal needs an established case of snooping
Agnes Michale v. Cheranelloor Grama Panchayath (Kerala HC, 2023)Admission-stage order impleading the State Police Chief to frame CCTV guidelines; we have not traced any issued since
Kawaljit Kaur v. State (NCT of Delhi) (Delhi HC, 2026)Held that a complaint about a rotatable camera with sound recording, said to cover a flat's entrance, was a civil dispute not suited to a criminal writ

None of these courts applied a data protection law.

Where the DPDP Act comes in

The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 speaks to the question the order left open, because footage from a networked home camera is digital personal data.

A neighbour who decides where to point the camera and what to keep is therefore, on the definitions alone, a Data Fiduciary.

The exclusion sets two conditions

Section 3(c)(i) says the Act does not apply to:

personal data processed by an individual for any personal or domestic purpose

The processor must be an individual, and the purpose must be personal or domestic. The section says nothing about where the camera is mounted or what falls within its frame.

Under the Act, section 3 itself, the grounds for processing in sections 4 to 7, the obligations in section 8 and the penalty provisions take effect only on 13 May 2027. Until then nobody can take a neighbour's camera to the Data Protection Board, which leaves courts and practitioners about six months to work out how the exclusion should be read.

Three ways to read section 3(c)(i)

On a literal reading, home security is a domestic purpose and every household camera is excluded wherever it points. That would leave a petitioner like Yogendra Maurya with no remedy under the Act even if the camera did nothing except record who came to his door.

A spatial reading, which is how the EU approaches its own household exemption, would end the exclusion once the camera covers any space outside the home, while a purpose reading would end it once the camera is positioned or used to watch another household.

Indian drafting history cuts against the European test

In František Ryneš v. Úřad pro ochranu osobních údajů (2014), the CJEU held that a camera covering even part of a public space is directed outwards from the private setting and is not a "purely" personal or household activity. The Indian text moved the other way:

A possible conclusion is that Parliament chose a wider exclusion than the EU's.

Where the camera points is evidence of why it was installed

The purpose reading stays within the text. Widening the range of personal purposes does not turn a different purpose into a personal one, and a camera positioned to log another household's visitors serves the purpose of watching that household. Indian courts already reason this way:

A narrow reading of the exclusion also fits an Act that sets out to protect the right of individuals to their personal data, a right the Supreme Court recognised as fundamental in K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India (2017).

Outside the exclusion, the DPDP Act has no legitimate-interests ground

Section 4 allows processing only with consent or for a legitimate use listed in section 7, and none of those uses covers ordinary home security. Section 7(h) reaches only disasters and breakdowns of public order.

When Mr Ryneš lost the household exemption, the CJEU noted that the Directive still allowed his legitimate interests, such as protecting his family's property, health and life, to be taken into account, since the camera had been put up after repeated attacks on the house. An Indian homeowner whose camera falls outside section 3(c)(i) has no equivalent ground, and unless section 17(1)(c) applies, would need the consent of every visitor the camera records.

Section 17(1)(c), and the cameras section 3(c)(i) cannot cover

Section 17(1)(c) disapplies most of Chapter II, including sections 4 to 7, where personal data is processed "in the interest of prevention, detection, investigation or prosecution of any offence". A camera covering a gate or a parking spot to deter theft has a credible claim to that exemption, while a camera aimed at a neighbour's door to record who visits has none.

Resident welfare associations and housing societies cannot use the domestic exclusion at all, because they are persons under section 2(s)(v) but not individuals, so the common-area cameras they install fall within the Act. Cameras in malls, shops, hotels and offices are within the Act as well, since the business running them is usually a company rather than an individual, and even a sole proprietor's shop camera serves a commercial purpose rather than a personal or domestic one. The same is true of device and cloud providers that process footage for their own analytics, which are Data Fiduciaries themselves.

The Board can fine a neighbour but cannot compensate the person recorded

Penalties imposed by the Data Protection Board go to the Consolidated Fund of India under section 34, and nothing in the Act lets the Board award compensation to the person recorded. A neighbour who complains also takes on a duty under section 15(d) not to file a false or frivolous complaint, which carries a penalty of up to ₹10,000, and section 39 may bar a civil suit framed only as a breach of the Act.

Scottish law gave neighbours a damages claim that the DPDP Act does not. In Woolley v. Akbar (2017), a sheriff in Edinburgh awarded each of two neighbours £8,634 under the Data Protection Act 1998, calculated at £10 for each day their data had been processed by a CCTV system deliberately set to cover their property, less a month a year for time they were likely to be away.

A workable test

Until a court or the Board rules on section 3(c)(i), homeowners and their advisers can work with three questions.

  1. (i) What does the lens cover beyond the home's own entrances, compound and parking?
  2. (ii) Does the camera record audio?
  3. (iii) Would the coverage still make sense if the only aim were to protect the home?

A camera that fails them is likely to be treated as watching the neighbour, under the DPDP Act from 13 May 2027 and, after the Allahabad High Court's order, under the general law today.

Sources

  1. Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, sections 2(i), 2(s), 2(x), 3(c)(i), 4, 7, 15(d), 17(1)(c), 34, 39 and the Schedule.
  2. Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, Notification G.S.R. 843(E), 13 November 2025.
  3. Draft Personal Data Protection Bill, 2018, section 46; Personal Data Protection Bill, 2019, clause 36(d); Draft Digital Personal Data Protection Bill, 2022, clause 4(3)(c).
  4. Yogendra Maurya v. State of U.P., Writ-C No. 42270 of 2026, Allahabad High Court, order dated 26 October 2026.
  5. K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India (2017) 10 SCC 1; (2019) 1 SCC 1.
  6. Agnes Michale v. Cheranelloor Grama Panchayath, WP(C) No. 1485 of 2023, Kerala High Court, order dated 17 January 2023.
  7. Sumehar Chand Narwal v. State of H.P., Cr.MMO No. 993 of 2022, Himachal Pradesh High Court, judgment dated 10 January 2024.
  8. Sivasankaran @ Sankarankutty v. State of Kerala, WP(C) No. 8754 of 2025, 2025:KER:85261, Kerala High Court, judgment dated 11 August 2025.
  9. Kawaljit Kaur v. State (NCT of Delhi), W.P.(Crl.) No. 201 of 2026, Delhi High Court, judgment dated 20 January 2026.
  10. František Ryneš v. Úřad pro ochranu osobních údajů, Case C-212/13, ECLI:EU:C:2014:2428, Court of Justice of the European Union, 11 December 2014.
  11. Woolley v. Akbar or Akram [2017] SC EDIN 7, Sheriff Court, Edinburgh.

Topics

This note is a general account of the law at the date shown. It is not legal advice.

Related notes